Posted by agri_center | Posted in Politics | Posted on 31-08-2008
Tags: a Carabao Mango Variety, Carabao mango facts, Is Manila Mango of Mexico, Philippine Mango facts
The issue of using Manila as brand name of Mexican mangoes got some Filipinos angry including me because for one, it was an advantage for Mexico because for a while Filipinos in the US thought that Manila Mangoes from Mexico were Carabao mangoes, so it was misleading. But before we get upset or angry with the so called Manila Mangoes, lets do some researching so that we could understand the issue of a possible trademark infringements that Mexico can get from us from WIPO.
First, they say that Carabao mangoes were brought by Spaniards in Mexico in the Galleon Trade era where in Spaniards were bringing goods from Mexico in the Philippines and vice versa. So with that, Spaniards brought fruits and seeds of possible Carabao mango strain. But are we sure that they are all Carabao Mango strains? Sources say that the so called Manila Mangoes are not of the Carabao mango strain but probably of the Piko mango strain which are very sweet and with some little fiber.
In Mexico some of the mango varieties are Ataulfo (name of the person who planted the so called Manila Mango) in Chiapas, Mexico that came from Vera Cruz, Mexico then are branded as Honey or Champagne mango and they also grow the infamous Tommy Atkins, a not so good mango variety but due to its good production, its good for commercial mango variety and for export since other countries that don’t grow mangoes really don’t have any idea what really a good tasting mango is. And in mango growing countries, mango has an acquired taste meaning they have there own taste preference according to there origin. I cannot call it Mango Pride but more of an acquired taste.
So after Senor Ataulfo grew mangoes from Chiapas from Vera Cruz, it is now the standard commercial mango variety along with other imported varieties. So, if you’re going to look at it, the mangoes from Philippines probably where planted in Vera Cruz then planted in Chiapas. So to conclude, the mangoes from Mexico that came possible from the Philippines were either Carabao mangoes or Piko but maybe a hybrid or a variation of both varieties. In my opinion, the mangoes that were brought in Mexico are probably of the Piko variety because from descriptions, Manila Mangoes are sickly sweet meaning very sweet which a Piko mango is also.
So, we conclude that the Manila Mangoes of Mexico are not Carabao Mangoes maybe. So why must we react on the Manila Mango issue with Mexico? We should react because Mexico can be penalized for trademark infringements for misleading a product. If you don’t know our official brand name of our Carabao mango in the international market is Manila Super Mango and it is in my knowledge that we have a trademark for this brand name in Intellectual property rights organizations. So, if you have a trademark filed internationally, you can file trademark infringement for using the Manila and for misleading consumers especially Filipino in other countries which could have damaging effects for our exporters and growers. So, in the end, we are not fighting who has the best tasting mangoes in the world but we are fighting for intellectual property rights, we first used and own the Manila domain name, so it is right that we are the only one to use it in terms of branding our mango fruits to keep up the quality and consistency of our Carabao mangoes in the world in terms of that it came really from the Philippines. Agricultural Politics at its best.
In the video, the guy is explaining that the Mexican mangoes are not Manila Mangoes or what he means that they were not grown in the Philippines. And he maybe is right that the Mexican mangoes or Ataulfo mangoes are hybrids or variations of mangoes brought in by the Spaniards in the Galleon Trade centuries ago.
So the question now Is Manila Mango of Mexico, a Carabao Mango Variety? No, it is not, maybe its a hybrid or new variation of mango variety that came from the Philippines. But Mexico should use there own mango brand like Ataulfo and not use Manila because they want to penetrate Filipino market in the west coast of USA like California. In using Manila Mango, they don’t have any explanation yet. Looking at the bright side, pirating a brand name is a form of complement which means that our Carabao mango really is one of the best tasting mangoes.
Video Source: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUjDKMp27Lo



